Before he gave us a silly old bear, A.A. Milne tried his hand at a classic whodunit, and the result is an absolute charmer. It’s a book that feels like a sunny afternoon spent solving puzzles with a clever friend.

The Story

Antony Gillingham arrives at the Red House for a visit, only to walk into chaos. His friend is hosting a party, and the host’s long-lost brother, Robert, has just shown up. Minutes after a loud, angry argument is heard, Robert is found dead in a locked study, and the host has vanished. With the local police out of their depth, Antony teams up with his eager friend Bill to investigate. They interview the quirky guests, search for hidden clues, and race to find the missing man before he’s presumed guilty of murder.

Why You Should Read It

This isn't a dark, gritty thriller. The joy here is in the playful investigation. Antony isn’t a brooding genius; he’s a cheerful, observant fellow who enjoys the game of it all. His dynamic with the devoted Bill is genuinely funny and warm. Milne’s writing sparkles with the same gentle wit you’d expect, making the dialogue a real treat. You can feel his love for the detective stories of his day, and he executes the formula with style and affection.

Final Verdict

Perfect for fans of Agatha Christie’s lighter cases or anyone who loves the puzzle-box appeal of a traditional English mystery. If you’re curious about Milne’s other work or just want a clever, low-stakes mystery that feels like a breath of fresh air, this is your book. It’s a forgotten gem that proves its author’s talent stretched far beyond the Hundred Acre Wood.